Your College Debt, Their Education: Balancing the Costs
Saving for a loved one’s education while paying off student loan debt of your own can be challenging. Here are strategies to help you strike that balance.
College is a big investment—in both your personal development and your financial future. But a major investment often comes with a major price tag.
In the U.S., the average cost of attending a four-year college, including books, supplies and daily expenses, is more than $36,400 per year—or $146,000 in total.1 So it’s understandable that many have turned to student loans to finance their degrees. Today, there are 43 million federal student loan borrowers each owing an average of more than $37,000.2
Student loans don’t only impact borrowers right after college graduation—nearly half of all student loan debt is held by those between the ages of 30 and 50.3
The “Standard Repayment Plan” for federal student loans is set up for ten years, but it takes the average borrower twice as long to pay off their debt in full—meaning you may be thinking about helping the next generation pay for their college experience before you have finished paying off your own.4
Many parents want to assist their children financially so they can avoid student loans, with three in four parent borrowers saying they put their own financial goals on hold to take out student loans for their children. 5
If you’re in this situation, maintaining your financial well-being will require finding a balance between your obligations and your support for your children. Let’s go over some approaches for managing these two important goals at the same time.
Strategies for Paying Down Student Loan Debt
Making certain adjustments to your student loans can potentially impact the total amount you’ll pay.
One option to consider is consolidating or refinancing your loans, which could lower your monthly payment, making room for contributions to a college savings account for your child. However, if you go this route, pay attention to any impacts on both your interest rates and repayment schedule. A single, lower monthly payment may offer ease and convenience, but it could extend your repayment term without offering any savings in the long term. You may also have the option to refinance federal student loans with a private lender, but keep in mind that there are potential downsides, such as giving up the benefits and protections that federal loans provide.
You may also want to set up automatic bill-pay. Not only does this help you avoid missing or being late on your payments, but it also can occasionally come with interest rate incentives.
Paying more than the minimum monthly bill, when possible, may help lower your total interest owed. One way to do this is to allocate any windfalls to your debt. If you receive a bonus, tax refund, equity compensation payout or other extra cash, consider using at least some of it to pay off your student loans. And if it’s a recurring increase—such as a raise—you might consider putting a percentage of it toward your monthly payments. These occasions would also be good times to revisit your budget.
Lastly, remember that if you’re in a deferral period—when payments are not required—any unpaid interest that accrues during this period may be added to the principal balance when your loan enters repayment. This “capitalized interest” can increase your overall debt load. As such, it can be wise to continue paying down interest to keep capitalized interest at bay and save you in the long run.
Strategies for Saving Up for a Loved One’s Education
First, if you’re saving for a loved one’s education, begin early. Giving yourself more lead time to build up your savings will spread out the financial burden and make it more manageable. And if you invest the funds using a specialized education savings account, such as a 529 plan, even small amounts of money will have the potential to grow, thanks to the power of compounding. You might experience some tax advantages too.
Note that you don’t need to have the full amount saved by enrollment day—you can continue contributing to education savings accounts and potentially growing earnings over the course of your child’s schooling.
While saving, it’s important to know exactly what you’re saving for. Will you be covering the costs in full, or only covering some, like tuition? How many people will you ultimately be saving for? Does your plan account for public or private school? Knowing that level of specificity about your goals can help you define a path to achieving them.
As part of building out your roadmap, you’ll also want to reevaluate your budget. While carving out room for the essentials—including your own student loan payments, an emergency fund and retirement savings—identify opportunities to steer some dollars toward your education savings goal for your children.
Other Ways to Pay for College
As you well know, if you have student loans, there are several ways to cover education expenses beyond personal savings. If you need to supplement the amount you’ve saved, you and your child can look into financial aid, scholarships (local, national, and through any affiliate groups) and work-study opportunities. You may wish to speak with a professional, such as a guidance counselor, financial aid officer or Financial Advisor, to discuss your options.
If needed, you can also take out a loan. You might consider co-signing on a student loan with your child, or taking out a personal loan or parent PLUS loan (also known as a Direct PLUS Loan), which is specifically designed for parents helping their children pay for college. For more information on eligibility and other details on parent PLUS loans, visit studentaid.gov.
The Bottom Line
We recognize the challenges that come with paying down student debt, including the ability to save for all of your other goals, like financing your child’s education. But you have options. Consider these strategies as you work to strike the delicate balance of saving up while paying down debt.
Individuals should consult their personal tax and legal advisors before making any tax or legal related decisions. Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC (“Morgan Stanley”), its affiliates and Morgan Stanley Financial Advisors and Private Wealth Advisors do not provide tax or legal advice.
Investors should consider many factors before deciding which 529 plan is appropriate. Some of these factors include: the Plan’s investment options and the historical investment performance of these options, the Plan’s flexibility and features, the reputation and expertise of the Plan’s investment manager, Plan contribution limits and the federal and state tax benefits associated with an investment in the Plan. Some states, for example, offer favorable tax treatment and other benefits to their residents only if they invest in the state’s own Qualified Tuition Program. Investors should determine their home state’s tax treatment of 529 plans when considering whether to choose an in-state or out-of-state plan. Investors should consult with their tax or legal advisor before investing in any 529 Plan or contact their state tax division for more information. Morgan Stanley Smith Barney LLC does not provide tax and/or legal advice. Any 529 accounts owned by a third party (a grandparent for example) will not have impact if withdrawals occur after the student’s junior year of college (due to the FAFSA reporting income from two years prior.) **Please note: As a result of recent legislation, beginning in the 2024-25 school year, savings withdrawn from a non-parent-owned 529 account will no longer affect a student’s eligibility for federal aid.
The views and opinions expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of Morgan Stanley. The information and figures contained herein has been obtained from sources outside of Morgan Stanley and Morgan Stanley makes no representations or guarantees as to the accuracy or completeness of information or data from sources outside of Morgan Stanley. Morgan Stanley is not responsible for the information, data contained in this document. Neither the information provided nor any opinion expressed constitutes either a recommendation by Morgan Stanley or a solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.